Holiday Menu

Thanksgiving Menu

Signature Pie

  • The Starry Night Signature SNOZBERRY | $18
    • Mix of Apple, Raspberry, & Blueberry. Best seller! 

Order online HERE

9″ Pies

  • Pumpkin | $12
  • Apple Crumb | $12
  • Blueberry Crumb | $15
  • Peach Crumb | $15
  • Cherry Crumb | $18
  • Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie – 1/2 Pie & 1/2 Cheesecake! | $18
  • Pecan Pie | $20
  • Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie | $22

Order 9″ pies online HERE

Pumpkin Spice Bread Pudding | $25

  • 12 – 15 servings. Topped with caramel. In foil pan to reheat at home!

Thanksgiving Dinner Cupcake Set | $25 for a 6 pack

  • Salted Caramel Chocolate, Red Velvet, Cinnamon Apple, Espresso, Maple Pumpkin, and Yellow

Specialty Thanksgiving Menu

Gluten Free Pies

  • Pumpkin | $22
  • The Starry Night Signature SNOZBERRY | $28
    • Mix of Apple, Raspberry, & Blueberry. Best seller! 
  • Pecan | $28
  • Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie | $30

Gluten Free Thanksgiving Dinner Cupcake Set | $30

  • 6 pack of: Yellow, Red Velvet, Chocolate, Chocolate Chip, & Spice

KETO Thanksgiving Items

  • Pumpkin Bread | $9 per loaf
  • Keto Pumpkin Pie | $22
  • Keto Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie | $28
  • Spice Cookies | $20 per dozen
  • 8″ Single Layer Pumpkin Cake with Cream Cheese | $20
  • 8″ Keto Pumpkin Cheesecake | $30

Holiday Menu

Rudolph Cake | $45

  • 6″ Cake serving 10-15 people. 3 layers of cake & filling of choice
  • Red nose, fondant ears, and chocolate antlers!

See photo and online ordering options CLICK HERE!

Buche De Noel | $35

  • The infamous Yule Log! Sponge cake with your choice of mousse topped with chocolate, snow, mushrooms, reindeer, and holly
  • Mousse options: Chocolate, Raspberry, or Mocha
  • Serves 12 people

Cheesecake | 8″ for $25 | 10″ for $35

  • Pick your flavor! Cherry, pumpkin, blueberry, espresso, mocha, turtle, strawberry, red velvet, caramel, or Oreo crunch!

For all options and online ordering CLICK HERE!

Dazzling Cookie Tray | $30

  • Top seller for 15 years!
  • 3 dozen mixed cookies on a gift wrapped holiday tray, tied with a big bow. Perfect for office, client, or hostess gift!

Signature Pie

  • The Starry Night Signature SNOZBERRY | $18
    • Mix of Apple, Raspberry, & Blueberry. Best seller! 

Order your Snozberry online HERE

9″ Pies

  • Pumpkin | $12
  • Apple Crumb | $12
  • Blueberry Crumb | $15
  • Peach Crumb | $15
  • Cherry Crumb | $18
  • Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie – 1/2 Pie & 1/2 Cheesecake! | $18
  • Pecan Pie | $20
  • Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie | $22

Order 9″ pies online HERE

Holiday Cupcakes

  • Your choice of flavors topped with holiday decorations! Our full list of cupcake flavors are available year round.
  • Specialty holiday flavors include: Eggnog, Peppermint Bark, Pumpkin, Cinnamon Roll, Tipsy Elf, and The Grinch.

New Years Sweets!

Assorted Miniature Dessert Trays

Custom built for your party!

  • Beautifully arranged on a serving tray. Pop off the lid and you’re ready to party!
  • Pick your favorites: Fruit tarts, chocolate mousse cups, eclairs, cream puffs, mini cheesecakes, cannolis, and french macaroons
  • 3 mini desserts per person | $4.75 per person | 10 person minimum

Order online HERE, stop by the shop, or call us to order over the phone today! 410.871.9131